Neverland holds a baking competition each year, and three children from another world are selected as judges. Peter Pan's task is to find three children who genuinely love cake. While searching, he meets Wendy and falls for her immediately. Against Tinker Bell's advice, he selects Wendy and her two brothers — despite the fact that the brothers do not actually like cake. What happens to Wendy in this strange new world depends on the choices made along the way.