Chapter 5 picks up directly after the end of Chapter 4: Safe Haven. The Player has just had a dangerous encounter with Huggy Wuggy, while Kissy and Poppy have been captured and imprisoned by Lily Lovebraids. With Giblet and Chum Chompkins now working alongside them, the group begins to crystallize a final plan—one aimed at destroying The Prototype and ending the torment that has consumed Playtime Co. once and for all.